Entry 14

September 9
It is dangerous, I think now, how comfort works on a man who has spent days being quietly frightened.
Eileen found me first, which I mention only because it was the first time I had not had to go looking for one of them. She came to my cabin door mid-morning with a plate of something she’d baked—I want to say cornbread, though it might have been a coffee cake gone slightly wrong—and she had the unhurried manner of a woman who had never once in her life worried about overstaying a visit.
“You looked like you could use feeding,” she said, which was either kind or presumptuous, and with Eileen I never quite decided which.
She was, as I’ve said, everyone’s grandmother—soft in the way grandmothers are soft, quick to laugh, quicker to fuss—and sitting across from her at the small cabin table, eating cake that was in fact slightly wrong, I felt something loosen in me that had been tight since the coffee with Harlan. It is dangerous, I think now, how comfort works on a man who has spent days being quietly frightened. It makes him careless.
I asked about her life before the retreat, expecting grandchildren, a garden, a husband dead or divorced, the ordinary furniture of a woman her age. She gave me pieces of all of it, warmly, generously, and I believed every word, which is perhaps the most damning thing I can say about myself in this whole account.
It was near the end of the visit, when she was gathering the plate and the good humor was at its thickest, that she said—lightly, the way you’d mention the weather—“It’s nice, having you all back together again. Feels almost like old times.”
Together again.
I asked her what she meant, and watched—because I had learned, by then, exactly what to watch for—the half-second where her face tried to catch up with her mouth. She laughed it off beautifully, better than Claire had, better than Benita. “Oh, listen to me,” she said. “I say things. You get to my age, everyone starts feeling like someone you’ve already met.”
But her hand, I noticed, had gone still on the plate. Grandmothers do not go still. Grandmothers fuss.
“Eileen,” I said, “were you invited here, or asked?”
It was the most direct question I had put to anyone in two weeks, and I watched it cost her something to answer. “Both,” she said finally. “Isn’t everyone?”
She left not long after, taking the plate, leaving the cake, and I sat alone with the last of it going cold and understood—with the particular sickness of a man watching a puzzle complete itself faster than he wanted—that I could no longer explain away what I had heard from four separate people in four separate conversations as coincidence, or retreat small talk, or the blurring effect of shared time Claire had tried to sell me. Harlan knew things he shouldn’t. Claire knew things she shouldn’t. Benita had repeated Claire’s line to Eileen before I’d even heard it myself. And Eileen—sweet, soft, grandmotherly Eileen—had just told me, as plainly as any of them dared, that this was not the first time they had all been in a room together.
I looked down at my own hand, resting on the table beside the cold cake, and saw that the skin across both knuckles had gone the color and texture of something left too long in a dry oven—pale, faintly powdery at the edges, beginning, in one small patch near my thumb, to lift.
I did not eat the rest of the cake. I do not think I could have, even hungry, even comforted. Some part of me had already understood that comfort, in this place, was never offered without a cost attached, and I had just watched four people, one at a time, hand me the bill.
– Anonymous