JOURNAL,  JOURNAL ENTRIES,  JOURNAL PODCAST,  NEW

Entry 15

September 14

I no longer believe I am here by chance, and I no longer believe I will be permitted to leave the way I arrived.

I have put off writing this entry longer than any other, not because there was too little to say but because I have known, since the day it happened, that once I wrote it down there would be no walking it back—no convenient fog of retreat-blurred memory to hide behind, the excuse so generously offered to me, in turn, by Claire and Benita and Eileen. So let me say it plainly, the way none of them would: they all know each other. Harlan and Claire and Benita and Eileen and Larry—and Remy, though I have said little of Remy in these pages, and will say less now, because by this point in my account he had become almost decorative, a man who spoke often and revealed nothing, which I now understand to have been its own kind of loyalty. They were never strangers gathered by an advertisement. They were never seekers meeting other seekers for the first time over a fireplace story. They had done this before. I do not yet know how many times. I suspect, from things said and unsaid, that the number would frighten me more than the fact itself.

I want to tell you how I finally allowed myself to know this outright, rather than merely suspect it in the accumulating way I’ve already described. It was not a confession. No one confessed anything to me, not then, not for weeks after. It was a piece of paper.

I had gone into the lodge’s second floor—the one I mentioned, weeks ago now, assuming it uninhabited, an assumption that had already proven false once and would prove false again—looking for nothing in particular, only avoiding my own cabin and the questions I no longer wanted to ask out loud. There was a small room at the end of the hall, more closet than room, with a writing desk no one used and a drawer that stuck. Inside it, beneath a stack of receipts for propane and grocery deliveries, was a newspaper clipping, yellowed at the fold, no more than four inches of column. A body recovered from a ravine, some sixty miles from where I sat reading it. Unidentified, at the time of printing. The article was dated the week before our retreat’s advertised start.

I do not know, even now, that this was our eighth guest—the place setting I noticed and then talked myself out of noticing, that first dinner, when Phillip sat us six around a table meant for eight and no one remarked on the empty seat. But I know what I felt reading it, alone in that stuck-drawer room with dust in my throat: certainty, arriving not as a shock but as a settling, the way a foundation settles into ground that was never quite solid to begin with. Someone was supposed to be here. Someone did not arrive, or was not permitted to. And whatever happened to them happened before I ever packed a bag for this place.

I thought, reading it, of the missing eighth chair. I thought of Larry’s odd correction—“we were accepted,” he’d said, when I called it orchestration, as if the word orchestration were the offensive one and not the careful hierarchy it implied. I thought of Claire warning me, kindly, that noticing things was how people left early—and I understood, finally, standing in that dusty room with a decade-old clipping trembling slightly in my cracked and peeling hand, that she had not been talking about a retreat schedule. She had been talking about the ravine.

I put the clipping back exactly as I found it. I did not mention it to anyone, not Larry on the porch, not Phillip at dinner, not even in the private ledger I keep, until now, in these pages, where I have promised you the whole truth and mean to deliver it, however late.

I will say only this, and then move to matters I have avoided even longer than this one: I no longer believe I am here by chance, and I no longer believe I will be permitted to leave the way I arrived.

– Anonymous